Render Unto Trolls

Tunnels & Trolls 1st Edition (1975), 2026 Render

In April 1975 a librarian in Phoenix looked at 3 Little Brown Books, decided ten dollars was too much to pay for them, and went home to write his own game. By June, Ken St. Andre had produced 100 copies of Tunnels & Trolls off the Arizona State University print shop. It was the second fantasy roleplaying game ever published. It was also the early evidence that the hobby had no one true way.

Ken died on November 15, age 79. I’ve spent the past week with his first edition and these are my observations.

A Primary Source

I’m a historian by training, and I read early RPG rules the way I’d read any primary source. They provide insight into what people believed about this hobby before anyone had agreed on what it really was. The 1975 T&T rules are a good example of this period. The rules are loose, funny, and openly unfinished. Ken tells the Dungeon Master to change anything that doesn’t work. He calls the game “his” only in the sense that he paid to get it printed. All of this typed on a 1917 left-handed Remington.

The Problem

Ken reprinted the first edition in 2013, and a scan of that reprint resides in the Internet Archive. That reprint is faithful to the original typewritten pages, and is difficult to read. The type is faint and uneven, and on a ditial screen it’s worse. The Internet Archives searchable text layer is so garbled by OCR that it is near useless.

The 2026 Render

Faced with this problem I’ve rendered again the 2013 reprint. The full text was rebuilt from the archive scan, and every OCR error was checked against the page images. All 45 tables were rebuilt with clean page breaks: monster dice, saving rolls, levels and titles, all seventeen levels of spells, and Ken’s advanced weapons charts. The illustrations from the 2013 reprint are excluded. Ken’s spelling, grammar, and the occasional arithmetic slip are kept exactly as he typed them. As a reference copy the intent here is to show the original, not improve on it.

The 2026 render is provided here as a PDF for reading and printing, and as a Markdown file to aid in search, citation, or extraction.

Fare Thee Well, Ken

Ken gave us fifty years of permission to make the game our own. My condolences to his family, his friends, and every player who learned to delve because of him.

Thank you, Ken.

In Support of the Silver Prince

Wieliczka Salt Mine, Galicia; ARTIST Name: Rocault, Jules; BOOK Title: Les merveilles de l’industrie, vol. 1; Author(s): Figuier, Louis; Publisher: Paris: Furne, Jouvet et Cie, 1873

I’ve been running a bi-weekly game for a group of regular players for the past 5 years. This year we’ve been engaged in a historians’ exercise of AD&D 1e “rules as written”. Anthony Huso has been our librarian who has introduced us to this Herculean effort, though our own study of the text has been rewarding as well. In fact, i have been publishing my own AD&D 1e learnings here on this blog when I have something worthwhile to share.

We are playing Huso’s epic “Castle of the Silver Prince”. This campaign begins at level 0 and includes all the nuisanced AD&D stuff: training, weapon speed, combat segments, percent based reaction rolls and more.

The campaign does refer to an abandoned ruby mine as an adventure location, but is unkeyed. As our play moved closer and closer to the ruby mine I experimented with actually keying an AD&D 1e dungeon.

You can find that key along with some notes on how I approached the work here.

You can find a summary of our campaign events here, recorded an managed by Archivist AI.

Vancian Stacks

Trinity College Library, Dublin, Ireland
britannica.com w/ Prisma Gothic filter

In March ‘26 I read Matt Schumer’s “Something Big Is Happening”, which encouraged me to explore AI more than scratching I had been doing at the corners. Copilot, Notebook LM, Gemini Gems are all things that I had experimented with; most as search without ads, research primers, and custom agents to help shape complex messages.

Schumer fired my imagination in his descriptions of software development through natural language and the concept of machines building machines. Here was an opportunity (for $20 a month) to try my hand at building software applications that I dreamed of as a washed up CS undergrad who happily cut over to history. Like many of my technology adventures I apply them to my hobbies first to help me learn their practical and professional applications.

I started big, I mean really big. Why not build a tool that could be used to play Holmes & Clark solo. I wrestled with context preservation, establishing design principals, project instructions, false declarations, and genuine hallucinations. It was great!

I scaled back in some areas, established a framework that is improving results, and in support of my regular AD&D 1 Eeeeeee game tinkered with some Claude.ai skills to serve my immediate needs and produced:

  • DMG Appendix A – Random Dungeon Generator – in progress
  • DMG Appendix C – Random Dungeon Stocking – done
  • DMG Appendix C – Random Party Generator – done
  • DMG pg xx – Random Gems & Jewelry – done
  • Custom Magic-User Spellbook Generator – supporting PHB, UA, and Wizards Spell Compendium via data sourced from What’s In Your Spellbook (thank you Delta) – done

The spellbook generator is based on principals I’m using to define higher level characters, where spell and magic item selection are significant blocking points in my preparing for play quickly.

Here’s a sample library of spellbooks & user guide, both prepared in just a few minutes by the Claude.ai skill that could produce trillions more in whatever combination might be of interest.

Please let me know if there is any interest in reading more about how I’ve been experimenting with AI or if the above skills might be useful to you too.

Urmalk the Boundless

Prisma Gothic filter of the Echoes From Fomalhaut No. 12 players map

Open Tables

Packing for DunDraCon 49 last weekend I grabbed a few copies of Holmes & Clark in the off chance of organizing a pickup game. Leafing through a few adventures eventually settled on Urmalk the Boundless as I had run it a few months earlier at North Texas RPG con.

This is a fine little adventure for levels 3 to 5 offering an outdoor sandbox location and an underground dungeon. The outdoor area has some very interesting keyed locations though much of the exploration here is done though a series of random table roles.

I had such a fantastic time running this adventure at DunDraCon I was committed to doing so again as soon as possible.

Random Tables

The exploration in Urmalk the Boundless is driven by random tables, a series of d10 rolls with some conditional modifiers applied to these rolls. A little fiddly at the table and a prepared list would likely help streamline the play experience. In support of that effort I prepared a Google Sheet to generate these results quickly and consistently, available here.

Real Tables

Some thoughts on running Urmalk the Boundless:

  • Provide the PC with the highest Wis some rumors
  • PCs approach the Necropolis from a random (1d4) direction
  • The Necropolis is 1d6 hours form the nearby town
  • Provide the players a token to show there position on the map
  • Mark off explored locations with more tokens on the map
  • Mark the DM map with location of keyed monsters so that it can be understood if they will be draw by a nearby commotion
  • At North Texas RPG Con ‘25 we had as few as 2 players all the way up to 12 at one point, this was an epic session easily over 10 hour, Jeff Dee joined us in the final hours and that was a real highlight
  • At DunDraCon 49 my badge read “Can’t we just play D&D?” A buddy gathered a group and we explored the Necropolis for about 3h
  • Have at least 6 pre-generated characters so players can jump in quickly

…and now for the news from Lake Geneva

There is a fundraiser going on for a Gygax memorial in Lake Geneva. Here’s your chance to be part of history.

I’m backing in for a paver but a worthy cause whatever you can contribute. The organizer, Paul Stormburg ran a game for me at Lake Geneva in the old Gygax house. Pretty special for me. Encourage you all to make the pilgrimage if and when you can.

Kickstarter link follows: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/617053430/gary-gygax-memorial-game-table-for-dungeons-and-dragons-fans

Some snaps of my 2024 GaryCon visit for the 50th Anniversary.

I’d also encourage you to check out the “When We Were Wizards” podcast. A great oral history of the dawn of D&D, link follows: https://pods.to/whenwewerewizards